Part of The Revenue Model Sets the Strategy
PMPM / PEPM
A recurring flat fee per eligible member or employee, independent of usage.
01
How it works
The digital health company charges a recurring flat fee per eligible member (health plan contracts) or per eligible employee (employer contracts), independent of actual platform usage or engagement. Revenue is predictable and tied to population size, not utilization.
Contract structures vary across the market. At the population level, a national payer might pay pennies per member per month across millions of covered lives. At the employer level, a self-insured company typically pays low single-digit dollars per eligible employee per month. The pricing correlates with population size: the larger the eligible pool, the lower the per-unit rate.
02
Why the Engagement Gate matters here
The Engagement Gate is the threshold a program has to cross before it produces value for anyone: enough of the intended users doing enough of the intended behavior, for long enough to count. What varies by model is how long a closed gate can stay invisible, and here the fee is owed on the eligible population whether or not anyone crosses it. The full treatment sits on the Engagement Gate page.
PMPM invites CS complacency in a way the other models don't. Because the buyer pays regardless of whether members use the platform, there's a tendency to treat engagement as a nice-to-have rather than a must-have. The monthly invoice arrives on time. The revenue looks healthy. Everyone relaxes.
This is the guaranteed revenue trap. Today's invoice is safe, but the renewal is not.
- CPT / RPMNear immediate
- SaaS Platform LicensingRoughly 12 months
- Value-Based / Outcomes-Based18 to 24 months
- PMPM / PEPM24 to 36 months
When the contract comes up for review 24 to 36 months later, the buyer's executive sponsor has to justify the spend to their CFO. If engagement is sitting at a fraction of the eligible population with no demonstrable outcomes, the program looks like an expensive line item that produced nothing. The contract doesn't renew, and the loss feels sudden even though the warning signs were visible for two years.
03
The enrollment-based variant
The enrollment-based variant is the market's answer to that exposure. Buyers pay only for members who actually enroll or meet defined engagement thresholds, rather than for the full eligible population. This structure changes the CS operating model even though the external stakeholders and their value drivers remain largely the same.
Under traditional PMPM, the CS team's effort concentrates on retention and outcomes, with activation a secondary call on resources. Under enrollment-based pricing, that ordering inverts. Activation becomes the primary revenue driver because every member who doesn't enroll is revenue that never materializes. That pushes CS toward capabilities that look more like B2C growth marketing: multichannel outreach sequences, enrollment funnel optimization, incentive design, and A/B testing. Whether the vendor gets to run any of it is a separate question. Where the contract routes all member-facing communication through the buyer, the vendor builds campaigns rather than running them. This is the model where the marketing-inside-CS skillset becomes most critical.
The per-member price sits on a spectrum. At the population-health end, where the vendor serves millions of lives at pennies per member, revenue floats independent of engagement until renewal. At the engagement-gated end, where the vendor is paid dollars per enrolled member, revenue is directly and contractually tied to user behavior. Between the two ends sits a structure that prices on a defined subset. The parties agree on a targeted population smaller than the eligible one, the fee attaches to that number, and the reported utilization rate divides by it. The denominator stops being a reporting choice and becomes a negotiated term. This spectrum is the financial expression of the Engagement Gate: the closer revenue is tied to engagement, the higher the per-unit price, and the more critical CS activation capability becomes.
There's a unit-economics layer underneath this spectrum. Activation isn't just a capability, it's a cost line: outreach campaigns, incentives, staff time, and channel spend all carry a price per enrolled member. Under enrollment-based pricing at low single-digit dollars per member per month, the cost to activate a member can exceed the revenue that member generates for months. Before committing to an enrollment-gated contract, CS and finance need a shared answer to a simple question: what does it cost us to enroll one member, and how many months of revenue does it take to recover that cost? The answer determines which activation investments are affordable, which populations are economically viable to pursue, and whether the contract's pricing can support the engagement machine it requires.
What to settle before you sign
Under enrollment-based pricing, the definition of an enrolled member isn't a reporting convention. It's the billing denominator. That changes where the definition belongs.
These contracts can specify enrollment as a list of completed in-product actions rather than as a signup: creating an account, selecting a program or community, completing a profile or intake step, and answering a baseline assessment. Complete the set and the member counts as enrolled, often for a fixed period such as twelve months, with a separate and usually looser definition governing what counts as re-engagement after that. Registration and enrollment become two different populations, and only one of them generates revenue.
That structure is more demanding than it looks. A member who registers and stops halfway through the sequence is a real user of the product and a zero on the invoice. The gap between those two counts is the activation problem stated in dollars.
So three questions belong in the contract alongside the rate: which specific actions constitute enrollment, how long enrollment persists once earned, and what re-establishes it afterward. Settle them before go-live, when both sides are motivated to agree, rather than at the first business review, when one side has a number it doesn't like.
One more piece of arithmetic worth doing before signing. Contracts that pair a monthly minimum with per-enrolled pricing have a break-even enrollment count, the number at which the per-member fees finally consume the floor. Below that count the buyer's effective cost per enrolled member climbs, and it climbs steeply.
Effective monthly cost per enrolled member, as a multiple of the sticker rate
A program running at a quarter of its break-even enrollment can be paying several times the sticker rate for every member it actually activated, while the vendor collects the same floor either way. Both parties should know that number on day one, because it's the number that determines whether the deal renews.
Enrollment-based pricing raises a second question the rate doesn't answer: who is allowed to do the work that produces enrollments. Many payer and employer contracts route all member-facing communication through the buyer. The vendor builds the campaign, the buyer decides whether and when it goes out, and the buyer's calendar already carries other programs competing for the same channel. Under flat PMPM that's an engagement problem. Under enrollment-based pricing it's a revenue problem, because the vendor's revenue depends on work the vendor isn't permitted to perform.
Marketing-support sections are the standard answer, and they hold less than vendors assume. The common construction commits the buyer to review vendor content ahead of publication, to include the vendor in communications where channels are available, and to set frequency at its own discretion. Read closely, that's a statement of intent. The tells are approval rights over content, availability conditions on channels, and cadence left to the buyer's judgment. A vendor treating such a section as an activation commitment has misread it.
What holds is narrower. Obligations written as plain statements of what the buyer will do, review checkpoints fixed to dates rather than to milestones, and visibility into the buyer's own campaign calendar. None of that forces activation. What it does is create a standing forum where a shortfall becomes a joint problem early instead of a vendor complaint at renewal.
What this model does contractually, the Engagement Gate page does analytically. There, the question is which stage of the funnel sits under the line when a rate gets reported, and how far the answer can move a number that every party believes is accurate. Here, one of those stages has a price attached to it. Same distinction, different consequence: a reporting choice on one page, a billing denominator on the other. Read them together before negotiating an enrollment-gated deal.
What to settle, in one list:
- Which specific actions constitute enrollment.
- How long enrollment persists once earned.
- What re-establishes it afterward.
- Who controls member-facing communication, and what the buyer has committed to do rather than to consider.
- The break-even enrollment count, where the contract pairs a monthly minimum with per-enrolled pricing.
04
Stakeholder value drivers and KPIs
| Stakeholder | What they care about | Value drivers | KPIs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Health plan executive sponsor (VP Clinical Programs, CMO) | ROI demonstration, member outcomes, strategic differentiation | Cost avoidance for engaged members; quality measure improvement (HEDIS/Star Ratings); member retention; board-ready impact narrative | Total cost of care per engaged member vs. matched control; HEDIS measure lift; member retention rate (engaged vs. non-engaged); Star Ratings contribution |
| Health plan operational lead (Director of Care Management) | Program performance, operational smoothness, internal credibility | Member engagement rate meeting targets; integration stability; internal stakeholder satisfaction | Member engagement rate (active users / eligible population); 30-day member retention; integration uptime; QBR executive sponsor attendance |
| Employer HR / benefits leader | ROI on benefits spend, employee engagement, reduced absenteeism | Demonstrable engagement rates; measurable health impact; competitive benefits positioning; minimal administrative burden | Employee enrollment rate (enrolled / eligible employees); biometric improvement trends; healthcare cost trend vs. benchmark; absenteeism metrics; HR hours per month managing vendor |
| Members / employees | Ease of access, personalized support, feeling healthier | Accessible low-friction experience; relevant content; tangible personal improvement; trust in privacy | Time to first engagement; session frequency; program completion rate; self-reported outcomes; NPS |
| CS team (internal) | Renewal readiness, activation performance, expansion signals | Strong engagement narrative for QBRs; scalable activation playbooks; proactive risk detection | Customer health score; NRR and GRR; time-to-value (contract to first activation wave); renewal forecast accuracy |
05
How the buyer's payment environment shifts the value story
PMPM and PEPM contracts typically sit on the "reducing costs" side. The buyer is investing in a population health tool with the expectation that it will reduce downstream healthcare costs, improve quality metrics, or both. The value narrative is usually cost avoidance rather than revenue generation, which means the savings story CS builds often depends on data the vendor doesn't directly control. The exception is quality performance under Medicare Advantage. Star Ratings feed CMS bonus payments, so a quality gain there is money arriving rather than money not spent, and it belongs in the value story as revenue.
Medicare Advantage plans
ROI scrutiny intensifies. MA plans receive capitated payments from CMS, so every dollar spent on a PMPM digital health program must be justified by cost savings or quality measure improvements that drive Star Ratings. The QBR conversation centers on total cost of care reduction for engaged members and HEDIS measure performance. CS must secure access to claims data (often with a 6 to 12 month lag) and build credible cost-savings analyses, which frequently requires partnering with the plan's actuarial team or an external evaluator.
Medicaid managed care plans
The challenges are different. Member populations face real access barriers: lower digital literacy, limited device access, language barriers, and social determinants of health that affect every aspect of engagement. State-mandated quality measures drive the plan's priorities, and many state contracts now require health equity metrics. Those barriers change what works: SMS-first engagement strategies, multi-language support, and partnerships with community-based organizations often outperform standard digital outreach with these populations.
Engagement benchmarks only mean something when they're calibrated to the product type, the population, and the denominator being used. The same program can report activation rates that differ by an order of magnitude depending on whether the denominator is the total eligible population, the members who were successfully reached, or the subset who enrolled. Vendors tend to quote the friendliest version. A Medicaid result that looks like underperformance against a generic benchmark may be strong once the population's barriers and what the benchmark was actually measured against are both accounted for. CS teams that don't educate their buyers on this context risk having solid performance perceived as failure.
For deeper treatment of operating inside health plan accounts across these lines of business, including the full stakeholder map and QBR structure, see the Health Plans Lens.
Self-insured employers
The value conversation becomes a CFO conversation. Healthcare cost trend must improve measurably. Employee engagement must be visible enough that leadership perceives the benefit as worthwhile. And the HR team, which is typically lean, needs the vendor to minimize administrative burden. The language is financial: ROI, cost trend, productivity gains, and competitive benefits positioning.
06
Real-world example
At one enterprise behavioral health platform managing a portfolio of Fortune 500 employer clients, the CS team faced a common pattern: contracts were structured as flat PEPM, the invoices paid on time every month, and engagement hovered around 12 to 15% of eligible employees. The accounts looked healthy by revenue metrics. But when renewal conversations approached, the buyers consistently asked the same question: "What outcomes have we achieved?" The CS team had engagement data but no outcomes story.
The fix required two shifts. First, building a multichannel activation approach using personas, A/B-tested campaigns, and plug-and-play toolkits that clients ran themselves through manager communications, Slack channels, intranet placements, and targeted email sequences. This pushed activation rates significantly higher across the portfolio, with one client reaching 80% of eligible employees. Second, connecting that engagement to measurable outcomes that mattered to each buyer's specific context, whether that was reduced time-to-value, employee satisfaction scores, or utilization data that supported the benefits team's internal reporting.
The result was 100% net revenue retention and 95% client retention across the portfolio, because the renewal conversation shifted from "why are we paying for this?" to "how do we expand this to more populations?"
For more on the dynamics of operating inside employer accounts, including the gap between the HR contact and the budget authority, see the Employers Lens.
07
Where to go next
The Engagement Gate page carries the analytical half of the argument this page makes contractually: which stage of the funnel sits under the line when a rate gets reported, the rules for reporting one honestly, and the lag comparison across all five models. The other four model pages follow the same shape as this one: how the model works, how the buyer's payment environment shifts the value story, the stakeholder value drivers, and an example drawn from practice. The hybrid page maps contract structures instead, since a hybrid inherits its stakeholders from the models it combines.
The three buyer lens pages come at it from the other direction, covering how pharma, health plans, and employers each define value and what each one accepts as proof.
Take the working structures with you
The Field Kit pulls the framework's durable layer out into structures built for use rather than reading: the identify-your-model diagnostic, blank stakeholder and KPI worksheets, the tiered QBR builder, the hybrid trade-off script, the believable-proof checklist, and the seven-step guide to putting the framework to work on a live account. Version-stamped, designed to print, and free to subscribers, who get it first when it ships. Billing-code specifics stay on this site by design, so the kit stays accurate as the rules change.
Your email delivers the kit when it ships, plus occasional new insights from Digital Health Success. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.