Activation is a marketing problem living inside the CS function
Nobody decided customer success should own member activation. It landed there because CS is the only team whose number depends on it.
Joe Travers · November 10, 2026 · 6 minute read
At Twill my title was Director of Customer Activation and Retention. I didn’t think much about the wording at the time. Looking back, the title was an admission. The company had figured out that getting members to show up was its own job, that the job belonged next to retention, and that both of them lived in customer success. What it hadn’t figured out, and what I don’t think most digital health companies have figured out, is that the first half of that title is marketing work.
The Framework states this in one sentence on the Engagement Gate page and leaves it there. This essay is the argument behind the sentence.
How it ends up in CS
Walk through who could own activation at a digital health company and the answer is nobody else.
Marketing is pointed at buyers. In every company I’ve worked in, the marketing team ran pipeline: conferences, the website, the content that gets a health plan or an employer to take a meeting. That is the right job for them. It also means the day a contract is signed, the marketing team’s work on that account is done, right at the moment the hardest marketing problem begins.
The client’s own communications team is closer to the member, and they are hemmed in. Anything that touches a member’s health information limits the channel, the timing, and the message. Legal reviews the copy. The plan or the employer has a calendar of its own, and your program gets one slot in a benefits email that goes out in a quarter, if it gets one at all. (Although every client is different, “we can send one email in the spring” comes up more often than you’d expect.)
Product owns the experience once the person arrives. That work matters, and it starts after the thing we’re talking about. Onboarding flow, first session, friction: all of it assumes someone opened the door.
Which leaves the person at the end of the chain, who never asked for the product and has no obligation to use it, and one team whose number depends on whether they do. The renewal sits with CS. The QBR sits with CS. When the client asks why only a fraction of eligible members have enrolled, the CS leader is the one in the room. Therefore, it lands on CS. Usually nobody decides it. It’s just where the question keeps getting asked.
What goes wrong when CS treats it as onboarding
A CS leader who comes from SaaS has a playbook for this, and the playbook is training. Kickoff call, launch email, a webinar, help center articles, a check-in at thirty days. It works in SaaS because the end user was told to use the software. A manager bought it and expects them to log in.
Run that playbook against a health plan population and you get a launch spike and then a flat line. The launch email goes out on the client’s letterhead to a hundred thousand members who don’t recognize the program name. A few thousand click. Fewer enroll. Then nothing happens for three months, because the next outreach window is a quarter away and nobody on the team treats the gap as something to test. The conclusion the team reaches, quite frankly, is that the population is hard to reach. That conclusion is partly true and mostly an excuse. That population got a notice. Nobody marketed to it.
The Engagement Gate page covers what makes the gate hard to open (the member never chose it, trust comes before engagement, access varies across the population), so I won’t repeat it here. The point for this essay is that every one of those obstacles is one marketers have been working on in other categories for decades, and the CS team usually has no one on it who has done that work.
What the marketer’s toolkit looks like here
I spent close to ten years in digital marketing before I ran a CS team, at Corning Life Sciences, then EMD Millipore, then Boston Scientific. When I started building CS at Voluntis I didn’t have a CS playbook to fall back on, so I used the one I had. It turned out to be the right one for the problem.
The pieces are ordinary. Personas, but for the eligible population rather than the buyer: who in this plan’s book is most likely to act, what do they need to hear, and from whom. Channel, which in digital health means two questions that are usually answered separately: which channels the client will allow, and which ones the member will actually open. A message from the plan carries trust the company’s own logo does not, and the reverse is sometimes true with an employer. Testing, meaning two subject lines, two offers, two send times, run against each other and read, so that the next window is better than the last one. A calendar built around the contract: benefit launches, enrollment periods, the clinic’s own rhythm, whatever the client’s year actually looks like.
And then the part that makes it CS work rather than campaign work: reading the results against the contract instead of against the campaign. An open rate is a campaign metric. Activated members against the eligible population is the contract metric, and it is the one the buyer is paying for. The denominator section on the Gate page covers why the population under the line changes the answer by several times over. The activation plan has to be built against the denominator the contract uses, from the first send.
Again, none of this is exotic. What’s unusual is finding it on a CS team.
What to do about it
Three answers, and I’ve seen each of them work.
Hire a marketer into CS. Not a CSM who writes well. Someone who has run campaigns, owns the activation number, and sits in the QBR to defend it. On a small team this can be one person with a dotted line to the CSMs.
Or make the CS leader someone who has done the marketing work. That is the path I took, and I’ll admit it’s the one I’d argue for, so weigh that accordingly.
Or formalize the dotted line from marketing with a goal tied to activation against eligible lives, in writing, rather than to pipeline. Without the goal, marketing will help when they can, which means when they have nothing else on.
Whichever way you go, write the activation plan into the implementation plan and, where you can, into the contract. Who owns which channel. How many touches the client will allow and in what windows. Which population the activation rate will be reported against. Those conversations are easy before launch and ugly after a soft quarter, and the Gate page’s rule about fixing definitions early applies to the plan as much as to the metric.
I want to make sure I’m not overstating the case. There are digital health products where the first use is nearly automatic, because a clinician enrolls the patient in the room and hands them a device. RPM often works that way, and the hard part there is adherence and billing compliance rather than activation. With that said, the moment the member has to act on their own, which is the case under nearly every PMPM, PEPM, and value-based contract I’ve worked on, the argument above holds.
If you run CS in digital health and activation sits on your team, I’d like to know how it got there and who you have working on it.
Read next
The Engagement Gate
The Framework page this essay argues from: activation and adherence as different problems, the six positions a member can occupy, and how to measure the gate honestly.
The author
Joe Travers
Ten years building and leading customer success in digital health, after a first decade in digital marketing. The Framework and the crew on this site came out of that work.
Get insights as they’re published
New frameworks, interviews, and field reports, direct to your inbox. No fluff. Subscribers get the Field Kit first when it ships: the Framework’s working structures, built for use.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.